| |
 |
STREET
FEAR
by Hatto Fischer
hfischer@poieinkaiprattein.org
Speech given at the Conference Cultural
Capital Cities of Europe
Athens
Oct. 13 - 15, 2005
|
In this context of cultural capital cities coming together
to honor culture as a special form of governance,
With governance understood as dialog, as dance of the
imagination, as chance given to everyone to participate,
to open up doors and to extend horizons into the future,
So that culture can be sung about as imagined reason for
our self understanding,
|
|
We acknowledge that such culture depends upon people being not
merely productive as to when they build more cars and especially
jeeps to crowd the streets but upon them becoming creative when
answering questions of life. After all cultural governance is a
non violent way of people living and working together and rather
than seeking revenge or victories they speak with one another on
the basis of equality.
Consequently, in view of the need for cultural governance of
cities, one decisive question has to be posed due to what people
experience in cities of today:
Why street fear?
Meant is not the fear of parents for their children when playing
amidst cars making streets unsafe, nor what makes women afraid
to walk home alone at night, or us being fearful when not finding
our way in a strange neighborhood deemed unsafe by everyone,
for despite all this mingling and rushing of people through
the streets everyday, people of different colors, backgrounds,
odd ways of dressing and walking, when coming our way, alone
or in groups, no, they do not make us afraid even if they challenge
us in our own identities, but why then 'street fear' in this
21 st century?
There was that shout of a pedestrian in New York when he saw
that plane fly into one of the Two Twin Towers as if he could
not believe his own eyes: "o holy shit!"
Street fear was not buried then in the debris when those two
towers collapsed but arises, so to speak, out of the ashes like
the sphinx. It has marked us ever since as witnesses. By now
we know too many faces covered in dust all these bomb explosions
leave behind. People come out of such situations changed. The
woman with the white mask after the London bombing communicated
on that day to everyone watching 'breaking news' on television
street fear exists now permanently in our numbed souls.
Street fear tells us what we can expect, namely that the next
bomb shall go off unexpectedly. When it happens, there will be
drawn again a coincidental dividing line amongst innocent by-standers
by suicide bombers. The division is between those ripped out
of daily life as victims and those who were only brushed by death
but lucky enough to escape this time. Everyone knows he or she
could have been easily on the other side of that fine dividing
line. There is the sad story of that London girl who left the
underground to take the bus only to be blown up then. She may
have thought to have picked a safer route.
Street fear as metaphor says we no longer find refuge in cities
against violence, something Derrida still thought to be possible
provided cities respond immediately to violence by creating new
laws to ensure that non violence prevails. Such laws should let
everyone become creative and not suppress the other out of fear.
Instead we experience a kind of lawlessness or disregard for
civil liberties and human rights especially by those justifying
war over peace. No wonder we have problems drawing our mental
maps when trying to find our way. It is because the war zone
shifts all the time in this global war against terrorism. Terror
cannot be contained solely to the streets of Baghdad if lack
of respect for human life dictates lawlessness everywhere.
The Irish poet Brendan Kennelly expresses in a poem called 'Nails'
an outcome of his contemplation about 'poetry and violence'.
Here then a poetic interlude in dedication to all innocent bystanders
and victims: |
| |
Nails
The black van exploded
Fifty yards from the hotel entrance.
Two men, one black-haired, the other red,
Had parked it there as though for a few moments
While they walked around the corner
Not noticing, it seemed, the children
In single file behind their perky leader,
And certainly not seeing the van
Explode into the children's bodies.
Nails, nine inches long, lodged
In chest, ankle, thigh, buttock, shoulder, face.
The quickly gathered crowd was outraged and shocked.
Some children were whole, others bits and pieces.
These blasted cruxifixions are commonplace. |
| |
The poem asks simply if there is no other way to react than
to be outraged and shocked while left alone with street fear?
Some suggested after the 7 th of July bombing in London citizens
should be allowed to search the bags of others in case of appearing
suspicious. A white man tried to do so some day after while taking
the Northern Line. He started shaking hands with everyone as
sign of trust. When one black guy refused, he immediately started
to curse. It was pure panic with racial undertones. But what
terrible consequence of street fear, if people would start controlling
each other as if the police? Clearly if we do not come to terms
with street fear, we risk being without trust and cultural tolerance.
After the bomb blasts in London July 7 th people started to
eye each other with suspicion, but what happens to cities once
public trust in open spaces is gone? The timing could not have
been worse. London had just been awarded the previous day the
Olympics for 2012 due to being a model of the future. That model
stands for a multi-culturalism which allows different people
to live together. It was damaged then. It left many more people
outraged over multi culturalism than thinking about the need
for education to integrate people. Nor do they seem to take note
that once cities are designed only for consumption, they are
not open for other people with different models of existence
in mind.
Still, between defiance as many British people showed in the
London aftermaths and Bali people taking rice and holy water
to their Gods in order to blow away evil spirits, there must
be a way to bridge cultural differences when it comes to respond
to human tragedy. It is not what police investigations and military
actions can answer, for the important question of street fear
is not what will separate, but unite people? Salmun Rushdie declared
he is no longer afraid for his life alone for 'we all are targets'.
However, as one taxi driver in London pointed out one day after
July 7th, the common people forced to take the underground are
vulnerable and that differs greatly from the well off ones who
are protected!
Clearly street fear says divisions in society can deepen especially
if we fail to act in solidarity with the vulnerable ones: children,
women and men of all walks of life. Solidarity cannot be shown
when at war unleashing only destructive forces. Rather violence
must be halted in a non violent way and not by throwing people
out of jobs when trying to improve the economy. Solidarity amongst
people exists when violence cannot be used against any single
human being. That includes structural violence overriding human
rights. It is culture that needs creative and free individuals.
As to the asymmetrical warfare being conducted in Iraq where
the best equipped and organized army in the world fights 'invisible'
insurgents, it is not terror which is being defeated but ever
more people who feel threatened in their freedom. As the American
poet Sam Hamill points out, the US government has yet to realize
that an army cannot defeat terrorism since it is a tactic. As
long as this is not understood civilians suffer.
Bush speaks about the battle for the hearts and minds of people.
Well, they are civilians. However, when it came to Falluja, people
had to flee. Those who did not make it out in time, were caught
in between the two sides. While insurgents fought back traumatized
people became prisoners in their own homes. And once street fear
becomes too intense, people want to leave the city deemed now
unsafe. Again it is the vulnerable people who are in need of
walking every day through the streets. These are the arteries
bringing life into the cities. Without people in streets cities
are nothing.
Street fear can be aptly described as the emotional response
of people to being targets of arbitrary attacks. Too many innocent
people have lost already their lives in a warfare that does not
know where to draw the line. The war against terrorism over extends
itself for those in power fear to appear weak and vulnerable
like every human being in the street. It is this lack of identification
with the other as human being that makes violence possible in
a combination of both war and terrorism.
Cultural Capital Cities should recognize ' street fear '
as a humane way of questioning the politics of this war. People
do not want to be treated as mere passive victims, and they need
culture to understand not in rage, but in a civilized way, how
to advance non violence as prerequisite of peace. If the world
is to get out of the vicious cycle of violence in which the war
against terrorism has entangled everyone in, we need to listen
to what 'street fear' tries to tell us. Rather than give in to
a war in permanence, people wish an end to this war. Here Cultural
Capital Cities of Europe have a task to fulfill: to make such
an end through cultural governance possible. Otherwise things
will go terribly wrong. |
| |
 |
|
Image: Londonbombing2.jpg From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The
four London bombers, captured on CCTV, and released by
Scotland Yard on July 16, 2005. From left to right, Hasib
Hussain, Germaine Lindsay, Mohammad Sidique Khan, and Shehzad
Tanweer, pictured in Luton train station at 07:21 BST,
Thursday, July 7. Taken from
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/politics/4689739.stm#
Posted: October 6, 2005 04:32 PM by FOX NEWS
|
|
Bush: Iraq will be cleared of terrorists 'city
by city'
Fox News
WASHINGTON - Laying out a broad plan to win the War on Terror,
President Bush on Thursday outlined an approach that includes
public diplomacy, "city-by-city" fighting, military
support for Iraqis and ridding that country and the world of
terrorists.
"Our goal is to defeat the terrorists and their allies
at the heart of their power. And so we will defeat the enemy
in Iraq," Bush said to an audience at the National Endowment
for Democracy. The speech was originally scheduled for Sept.
11 to mark the fourth anniversary of the terror attacks on the
United States, but was delayed because of federal efforts to
respond to Hurricane Katrina.
"Our coalition, along with our Iraqi allies, is moving
forward with a comprehensive, specific military plan. Area by
area, city by city, we're conducting offensive operations to
clear out enemy forces and leaving behind Iraqi units to prevent
the enemy from returning," Bush said.
http://khon.com/khon/display.cfm?storyID=7835§ionID=1150 |
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|